On Monday, I attended a panel discussion sponsored by Institute of the Black World 21st Century Forum which included community leaders, activists, scholars and politicians on the growing debate on race in our country at Busboys and Poets here in Washington, DC.
In recent months, we have seen many incidents that have brought the issue of race to the forefront in recent months:
- Earlier this year, we saw the media controversy over the statements made by Reverend Dr. Jeremiah Wright.
- That event led to a speech on race by Senator Barack Obama.
- Obama’s speech led to Dr. Wright’s speech and press conference here in Washington, DC.
- Dr. Wright’s speech and press conference led to Senator Obama’s disavowal of Dr. Wright.
- A July 16th New York Times poll on race in America that indicates that Obama “isn’t closing the divide on race.”
- The program, “CNN and Essence Special — Reclaiming the Dream”, July 18-19th
- The National Conference on Race and Reconciliation in America convened at the National Press Club, July 24-25th by Former Secretary of Defense William Cohen (who is white/Jewish) and his wife (who is black), Janet Langhart Cohen.
- And of course CNN’s much discussed, ‘Black In America‘ report, July 23-24th
There was pretty much a consensus that the panelists were dissatisfied with CNN’s program, but one panelist’s comment stood out to me when he said that he felt that dysfunction in the black community is being defined as blackness itself. He mentioned that the problems of the poor whites in West Virginia for example are not highlighted as the “white experience”.( I’ll go further and point out that poor whites are called “white trash” to point out that they do not represent the norm when it comes to whites).
As a person who is troubled by all the racist comments and emails I get, I can really agree with this statement. On the other hand, I know that these pathologies are so extreme that we must ask ourselves if we can ignore the race/ethnicity question. Even those that make it out of the cycle of dysfunction have to face problems associated with the perception in peoples’ minds that we - particularly black males - are all criminal. This perception affects how non-blacks (i.e., police) treat us in middle and upper class neighborhoods and can lead to new problems for the adults and children.
Another common sentiment was CNN’s program didn’t cover any new for black people. In other words, this show was intended for non-blacks to learn about black people.
My hope is that not only will more panel discussions like this will take place throughout the country, but that some solutions will come out of it. We need to take this conversation in a totally new direction in which we discuss how we can meet the challenges that we all face.
We need a massive grassroots effort to get those not mired in these pathologies to volunteer their time. More college students should be encouraged to tutor and mentor inner city children. We must start to teach and encourage children the consequences of making bad choices on their personal lives as well as its detrimental effect on the community at large.
Like one of the panelists, I am tired of going over these statistics over and over again. It is time to move from anger to action, from blaming to solving. As JFK said, “Our task is not to fix the blame for the past, but to fix the course for the future”
This is the message that I am looking for in these discussions. I think many common people feel the same way, but just don’t know where to go to help where they can be most effective.
I think that right now, people are ready to be inspired - this is why Obama’s message of “hope” and “change” resonates. But I can not emphasize enough that it can not stop there. We can not leave the people feeling hopeless and feeling that there is no solution for these ills and no future for our communities. This is why I hope that not only will future conferences and dialogues like this become more extensive and grow, but that there will be a challenge put to the audience at the end of each session to help solve the problems rather than leaving with a sense of helplessness.
I don’t have the answers, but as we all come together from different walks of life (and races), we can come up with the genuine solutions needed in our communities. We are all in this struggle together and each of us - regardless of race - should see this as an American problem because what affects one part of our society ultimately touches all of us in some way.
More information on the panelist is below:
Dr. Ron Daniels, President, Institute of the Black World 21st Century and Distinguished Lecturer, York College, City University of New York and hosts radio talk show host.
Dr. Ronald Walters: Distinguished Leadership Scholar at the James MacGregor Burns Academy of Leadership, University of Maryland.
Makani Themba Nixon: Executive Director, The Praxis Project, a nonprofit organization helping communities use media and policy advocacy to advance health equity and justice.
Dr. Tricia-Bent Goodley: Associate Professor of Social Work, Howard University and former Chair and Chief Instructor of the National Association of Black Social Worker’s National Academy for African-centered Social Work and the National Public Policy Institute.
Nkechi Taifa: Senior Policy Analyst, Open Society Institute and an Adjunct Professor at Howard University Law School, teaching a seminar on “Racial Disparities in the Criminal Justice System.”
Dr. Michael Fauntroy: Assistant professor of public policy at George Mason University, where he teaches courses in civil rights policy and American government and specializes in race and American politics.
Joe Madison: Also known as “The Black Eagle” by his Radio-One WOL-AM listeners in Washington D.C. and nationally on XM Satellite Radio channel 169, is one of America’s top talk radio personalities. He has been named one of Talker Magazine’s 100 Most Important Radio Talk Show Hosts nine times. Frequent analysis on CNN.
Kenny Barnes: President of ROOT, Inc., which stands for Reaching Out to Others Together. This group is dedicated to ending violence and creating peaceful and safe communities. Co-Host of Spirit in Action on WPFW, 89.5, Pacifica Network, Washington, D.C.
Donna Edwards Democratic Candidate for Congress in Maryland: Will be first African-American congresswoman from MD. In such a heavily Democratic district, she is affectively the Congresswoman already.
Filed under: Politics, Race | Tagged: Black in America

“In other words, this show was intended for non-blacks to learn about black people.”
I agree. Everyone is so critical to the documentary (and it was somethings that they could have addressed before others…like HBCU graduations) but we have to understand that this documentary wasn’t designed for the “conscious” Black folks.
It was designed so that people outside of Black America (and some unconscious Black Americans) could see a more positive side of Black America. Instead of the rappers, drug dealers, and steller stars that represent Black America to most of the world…lets see some examples of the diversity of Black America…the good and the bad. Unfortunately, its hard to portray the true image in a 4 hour documentary.
What do you think about the House Resolution apologizing to African-Americans?
I know, I thought I dreamed I heard that on TV this morning; I guess I didn’t.
Tariq:
If everyone who talked about these issues would actually attempt to do something –because there is a lot to be done—then we could move forward.
Too many people are talking/complaining yet remaining passive instead of taking action. At my church, we have already started forming parental classes and an abstinence group.
I was surprised at the amount of people who were genuinely interested and wanted to get involved. Sometimes it just takes one person to actually speak up and take action that leads to motivating others.
I think it shows how far this country has come and how there is a willingness to admit when it is wrong. There were many other countries that were involved in the slave trade (including many that point their self righteous finger at the US) that have not apologized at all and to this day think they have done nohting wrong. I would even go as far as to say that when the “coast is clear” they will go back to the practice. The slavery in these countries was very brutal and they took young African boys, castrated them and made them into eunuchs
We still have yet to see an apology from them for this brutality. So I applaud the US for admitting its crimes
If this type of action can go “viral” then we can make some real progress in the black community
As salamu ‘alaikum,
Again, another excellent post! Your summary at the end essentially sums it up Tariq. I don’t think that we can continue to view the issues of African Americans through the lens of race. As long as we continue to view race through the lens of race then we will have a limited view. Here, I turn to the late efforts of El-Hajj, Dr. King and now Dr. Cornell West in moving to a “prophetic” model and standard. To place these issues into the light of ethics, morals and values and to call people to their Adamic nature.
Allah (swt) has honored the human being and until we hold ourselves to the prophetic standard and uphold our station as humans then we are handicapping ourselves. To take the “Black” issue and place it in this context, I think, will have the most lasting effects. Our issues are human issues. Every race, ethnicity, people and nation has their problems. You don’t think white folks have issues? They are some of biggest alcholics, drug abusers, rapist etc. Obviously it’s not exploited in the way that crimes amongsts AfAm are but that doesn’t mean it’s non-existent or even less in quality or quantity. The point here is that our [AfAm] issues are human issues and they require “human” solutions not race-centric solutions.
This is the direction that these dialogues and discussions need to go. This is why we have seen the move to take the Slavery case to the UN as a “human rights violation”. Quite honestly, I have gotten to the point where I really believe that white people more than any other have a stake in coming into our communities and working to help and find solutions. I don’t see it as a “black thing” or something “we” have to fix. We are all in the same boat. We either float or perish together.
…and Allah knows best…
P.S.
I second your comments on the House Resolution. I’m sure many will say it’s superficial but the acknowledgement itself, to me, is a step forward in healing the wounds. African Americans should put this in a good light and use as a means of growth instead of being cynical and pessimistic.
Yes! Actions speak louder than words…the same applies to the African-American community….and the same applies to the House and the government!
Salaam’Alaikum
@ Brother Abuhunain
If you have time check out the blog A Singular Voice by Abdur Rahman, I’d like to hear your opinions on my comments.
Salaam Mary Ann
P.S. Tariq has his link under D.C. bloggers
I can say, as a historian, I’m tired of hearing the historical legacy of slavery as the root of all our problems. It’s clear that inaction is the motor that keeps these problems going, its constant blame without looking and trying out solutions. It will be hard, no doubt, but I believe that we can make a difference. I’m all for putting efforts into effective projects. I’ll leave the talking for in the classroom.
Interesting article by a Black conservative
http://www.townhall.com/columnists/LarryElder/2008/07/31/a_black_conservative_lament
ASA, just wanted to let you know about the MAN boards
http://cybermessageboard.fatcow.com/ummah1/index.php
Thanks for blogging about the panel. Looks like your post has spurred lots of great discussion!
Be sure to join us for more events!
Best,
Busboys